With the world going through a global COVID-19 pandemic, anxiety and fear have become as normal as the words social distancing and quarantine. While the medical and scientific community is doing its best to overcome the spread of this coronavirus infection, the fact is that since this is a new strain of virus (SARS-CoV-2), in-depth research into it is required to develop cures, vaccines and recovery protocols on a global scale.

This research is going to take some time, like all research does. In the meantime, the rest of the world has to be vigilant, take all the precautions needed and preventive measures recommended. These steps can help stop the spread of the disease, while giving the medical community a fighting chance and increase the recovery rates of patients suffering from COVID-19 worldwide.

However, with some recovered patients relapsing - especially in China and Japan - panic regarding COVID-19 has increased. These cases of relapse are getting people worried that the entire process of testing positive, quarantine, hospitalisation and recovery will have to be repeated again, or that it’ll be futile in the face of a virus that refuses to go away for good.

Although it’s quite natural to experience this type of anxiety about relapses, it’s very important to remember that there have been - as of March 2020 - very few cases of relapses. Scientists in general do believe that once you have recovered from the COVID-19 infection, your body would have created antibodies that protect you from getting the infection again. Relapses are likely to occur only if the antibodies were not automatically created - which can happen if you’re older, or have an underlying condition that compromises your immune system.

Read more: COVID-19 prevention tips for older people and those living with chronic diseases

  1. How to know if COVID-19 infection is cured?
  2. Why are some cured patients of COVID-19 relapsing?
  3. What to do if you experience a COVID-19 relapse?
Doctors for COVID-19 relapse: Can you get coronavirus infection twice?

According to the current global treatment protocols, patients who have been tested COVID-19 positive have to go into an immediate quarantine - at home or in a hospital, depending on the severity of the symptoms, age, underlying conditions like heart disease, hypertension, diabetes, lung disease, etc. Once the current treatment protocol is complete, the patient is tested twice. 

It’s only after two consecutive negative RT-PCR test results that patients of COVID-19 are being discharged. Two tests are done to ensure no false negatives, and that the patient’s body has indeed developed antibodies against the COVID-19 virus and infection. 

However, since there have been some cases of relapses in China and one in Japan - where doctors and epidemiologists have ensured that the patients did have two consecutive negative tests - it begs the question if what scientists know about viruses and the production of antibodies actually works in the case of COVID-19 or not.

Scientists at the American Thoracic Society have found that recovered patients continued to shed the virus for days after two consecutive negative tests for COVID-19. The scientists - who did their study with 16 patients in Beijing, China - published their findings in the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine in a paper titled "Time Kinetics of Viral Clearance and Resolution of Symptoms in Novel Coronavirus Infection" on 23 March 2020. Of course, more research needs to be done to determine if this viral load is high enough to cause a relapse or infect another person. What the researchers did recommend, for now, was to extend the period of quarantine for patients by two more weeks after recovery.

myUpchar doctors after many years of research have created myUpchar Ayurveda Urjas Capsule by using 100% original and pure herbs of Ayurveda. This ayurvedic medicine has been recommended by our doctors to lakhs of people for sex problems with good results.
Long Time Capsule
₹719  ₹799  10% OFF
BUY NOW

Relapses of a disease as contagious as COVID-19 is a cause for concern. Patients who have been cleared to go home after two negative tests are naturally going to feel relief and look forward to their rehabilitation. However, a relapse can take a physical as well as a mental toll on the patient - not to mention the load it can be on an already overworked global healthcare community.

The current cases of relapses in China and Japan have therefore been studied properly to understand if the risk of relapse is high globally. Studies published in journals like Cell Death and Differentiation, the British Medical Journal and the International Journal of Infectious Diseases in March 2020 have thrown some light on these cases.

These studies reveal that there can be three causes behind these relapses:

  • The patients were simply not fully recovered despite meeting the discharge criteria, i.e. not showing any symptoms and swab tests, chest X-rays, etc., showing no visible presence of the virus.
  • The RT-PCR test results showed false negatives before their discharge, which means the virus was not eliminated completely.
  • The patient’s immune system was unable to induce any virus-eliminating response to COVID-19, despite the symptoms becoming less severe or abating completely. 

Given these causes, it’s very important to continue proper surveillance and treatment of existing patients to make sure their immune responses are properly monitored until complete recovery. These causes also need to be taken into account by researchers and epidemiologists attempting to create vaccines for COVID-19.

While it can be extremely worrying to experience a relapse of COVID-19, both for you as well as your loved ones, it’s important to not lose hope. This means that you’ll have to continue with your isolation, and whether you’re doing so at home or at a hospital would not make much of a difference mentally, since feeling anxious and cut-off from civilisation is quite natural during a crisis like this.

What you need to continue focusing on is defeating this virus and eliminating it completely from your system. Cooperate fully with all healthcare professionals and be patient with them. This is as much a novel scenario for them as it is for you. Keep in touch with your family and loved ones through phone calls and video calls. Focus your energy on eating well, exercising (if recommended by the doctors), reading books and meditating to de-stress.

Dr Rahul Gam

Dr Rahul Gam

Infectious Disease
8 Years of Experience

Dr. Arun R

Dr. Arun R

Infectious Disease
5 Years of Experience

Dr. Neha Gupta

Dr. Neha Gupta

Infectious Disease
16 Years of Experience

Dr. Anupama Kumar

Dr. Anupama Kumar

Infectious Disease


Medicines / Products that contain COVID-19 relapse: Can you get coronavirus infection twice?

References

  1. De Chang et al. Time Kinetics of Viral Clearance and Resolution of Symptoms in Novel Coronavirus Infection. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 23 March 2020.
  2. Chen, Dabiao. et al. Recurrence of positive SARS-CoV-2 RNA in COVID-19: A case report. International Journal of Infectious Diseases, 2 March 2020.
  3. Bao, Linlin. et al. Reinfection could not occur in Sars-CoV-2 infected rhesus macaques. bioRxiv - the preprint server for biology
  4. Shi, Yufang. et al. COVID-19 infection: the perspectives on immune responses. Cell Death & Differentiation (2020)
  5. Yuan, Jing. et al. Clinical Characteristics on 25 Discharged Patients with COVID-19 Virus Returning. medRxiv.org - the preprint server for Health Sciences
Read on app